“I did then what I knew how to do. Now that I know better, I do better.”
― Maya Angelou
Oh, newborn babies… I’m so looking forward to meeting my own third newborn this spring when he or she arrives. Babies are petal soft, smell heavenly, and they represent all that is perfect and pure in our world. What photographer wouldn’t be excited to capture these exquisite little beings? With the rapid growth of the photography industry, more and more photographers are venturing into newborn photography. Inspired by the very popular, gravity defying posing they see, new photographers are often eager to jump in and try these same poses. For good reason, newborn safety has become quite a heated topic on the internet. As a mother, former pediatric nurse and a photographer, handling tiny babies respectfully and safely is very important to me. I’m passionate about protecting these tiny people and I cringe when I see a photographer post a photo with a baby who looks unsafe to the experienced eye. Given the active debate about newborn safety, many of you cringe as well. Actually, many of us are doing more than just cringing. We are speaking up. We are educating. We are trying to teach better techniques and ideas.
I’ve read many well written articles on how to photograph newborns. I know there are excellent newborn workshops that are available to help teach others how to protect and photograph new babies. Photos have been generously posted that show examples of how a composite image is created by experienced photographers who are willing to share their secrets. These are things that are meant to help educate those who are new to photographing newborns on how to handle a baby safely. I’m so proud that the photography industry includes leaders like this who are willing to share their time, knowledge and talent to keep these little ones safe.
I’ve also seen something that is deeply disturbing to me. I’ve seen photographers posting harshly critical comments on other photographer’s business pages. I’ve read comments that include swearing, name calling and rudeness on these business pages of fledgling newborn photographers. I’ve seen the work of new photographers shared virally on facebook and forums in a way that is meant to ridicule and shame. I’m so ashamed that this is also part of our photography industry. It makes me think of an anti-bullying poster in my son’s school that reads. “Is it respectful? Is it kind? Is it helpful?”
I strongly believe that criticism can be a very valuable tool to learn from. But, criticism works the best when it is constructive. Criticism aimed at tearing down someone else’s character is bullying. Its mean and it rarely accomplishes more than inflicting hurt and causing the recipient to withdrawal. Constructive criticism on the other hand, it builds the recipient up, it teaches a better way, it encourages. Constructive criticism spurs change to happen.
When you see something you are passionately sure is wrong, take a moment or two to consider how you could best prevent the wrong from happening again. What can you say to make things happen differently next time? Your words are powerful, use them in a way that they do the most good. If newborn safety is what makes you fiery and passionate and unable to keep quiet, awesome! These little babies needs someone to advocate for them and teach new photographers how to respectfully handle them. But, let’s be kind.
A good place to start if you feel you must say something personally to the photographer is contacting the new photographer privately. Sharing your thoughts privately is a good way to show you respect them as a person and hopefully create a relationship that will encourage safe techniques. Kindly share your concerns, without attacking character. Share the name and contact info for a good newborn workshop. Share a blog post on safety. Invite them to come join us on The Bloom Forum and ask any questions they might have. If you feel you need to take action publicly to change the awareness of newborn safety, please do so without calling attention publicly to the photographer whose work you saw flaw in. Be respectful. Be kind. Be helpful.
Finally, if you are reading this and you feel like you might have crossed the line on facebook or elsewhere with your words, I encourage you to go contact that person. Write a simple apology and delete your comment. While words are hard to forget, an apology can go a long way to heal someone else’s feelings. Everyone makes mistakes, it can be hard to reign in our words and feelings when we see something we know to be wrong. Passion is great, passion fuels change. Just make sure you channel that passion in the way that best affects the change you’d like to see. From the very wise Maya Angelou… when you know better, you do better.
Meg Bitton, Thank you so much for allowing us to share your beautiful image.
So beautifully written Gretchen, I just love everything you said. When we know better, we truly do better, thanks for sharing so openly :)
thank you for this! it’s beautifully written, genuine and kind.
Well said. Thanks:)
What a well written article, Gretchen! Thank you for this! I am with you in encouraging everyone to help others learn in a way that is safe and constructive!
wonderful words in a week of extreme chaos. thanks for the good thoughts :)
Well written and well said.
I’ve been on the receiving end (not about newborns, just photography in general) and wondered how people could be so nasty. I’m so glad to see that not everyone agrees with those kind of actions. Thanks for posting this!! :)
This is very timely, and very helpful. Thank you!
Thank you so much Gretchen for writing what many of us have been wanting to express for awhile!!
And to everyone that reads this, please share this blog post and let’s get the word out about DOING BETTER!
Thank you!
Very well written. People don’t even consider that their words can impact a person’s business and livelyhood. I agree that safety comes first and needs to be pointed out but these cyber bullying tactics are unprofessional and make the industry look like it’s filled with mean, bored cheerleaders. If you want the industry to have standards and ethics, this is not the way to rally people to change the industry.
well said, gretchen. this is why i love BLOOM.
Great post. Thank you for writing this.
perfect! thanks for taking the time to write this!
Beautifully written!
such great words of wisdom that can applied to all areas of life. Thanks!
Where do we draw the line though? These are newborn humans that are being put at risk. Maybe some nastiness is in order. Maybe that’s what it will take for people to start taking the things they are doing seriously. Hurt some feelings or let someone hurt a baby? No we don’t have to be as nasty as what I’ve been seeing about it, but I will feel pretty nasty when my liability insurance skyrockets due to babies all over the country getting hurt. I’ll be pretty nasty when we’re all having to obtain a license to practice our art and we have costly regulations forced upon us. There is a time to be kind and a time to tell it like it is.
If your livelihood involves hurting innocent children, you probably should find a new hobby.
Thank you! I stand behind you 100%, the bullying must stop or we will destroy ourselves!
HI Mel, Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I agree that the seriousness of newborn safety can not be pushed aside to spare someone’s feelings. However, bullying, which includes name calling, profanity and threats to the photographer’s life crosses a line that makes us appear to be uncouth, wicked people. Firmly and respectfully standing up for a newborn safety at the risk of offending someone is a a risk worth taking. But it should never be done in a way that would belittle, shame and humiliate the party who made the mistake. You might find this article a good place to start in giving crictism without hate. Yesterday the photographer whose work was shared virally went from a couple hundred fans on her business page to over 1300 this morning. The photographers for newborn safety page was right at 233 fans this morning. I believe virally sharing the safety information will do more to change the lasiez faire attitudes towards newborn safety than the bullying will. Thanks for participating in the discussion. Gretchen Davis
How to criticize without being mean http://www.ehow.com/how_8052140_criticize-being-mean.html
Newborn Safety Facebook Page http://www.facebook.com/pages/Photographers-for-Newborn-Safety/272744742772951
what a great ready, thank so much for posting this!!
Amazingly written, Gretchen! So proud of being a part of this wonderful and respectful community that Bloom is!
So nicely said.
AMEN!!! On all accounts!!
Perfectly written Gretchen!
Gretchen! I am so proud of this article, Gretchen! I am so proud to be a part of such amazing photographers and people who understand the humanity of what we do and the responsibility of what we do and the message we at The Bloom Forum want everyone to know. We are here to be supportive on all fronts in a respectful way. We are positive people helping other positive people reach their photography potential. Newborn safety is of the utmost importance in all this and there are lessons to be learned, taught and then we must bring about positive change.
Gretchen, you have great way with words and I am so glad you chose to write this article. You have put to paper what the majority of us feel. I do hope the minority who have behaved so poorly will read this and follow your advice.
Very will written and important. Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts and providing me with my new favorite quote!
way to go gretchen! you so beautifully said what needed to be shared! thank you!!! xoxo
VERY well written, Gretchen from both view points. And another Maya Angelou quote …”I’ve learned that people will forget what you said, people will forget what you did but people will never forget how you made them feel.” There IS a right and wrong way to handle disagreements….
Standing ovation! I applaud for you for posting this :)
WELL SAID! Thank you for posting this! I’m so tired of seeing photographers tear each other down. It’s sad. :(
Great post!
Well said!!!!
Pingback: Bloom’s Peace 2 Sandy Hook Project » Everything Bloom